Louise O’Brien on Elizabeth Smither:
Elizabeth Smither tends to be described first as a poet, having published her first collection Here Come the Clouds in 1975 when she was in her mid-30s. Since then, she’s won the Poetry Section of the New Zealand Book Awards (1990), the Montana New Zealand Book Award for Poetry (2000), been named Te Mata New Zealand Poet Laureate (2001-3), and received the Prime Minister’s Award for Literary Achievement in Poetry (2008). Critics admire her idiosyncratic style, witty and intellectually curious, which is usually (but not always) unrhymed, usually (but not always) brief – even miniaturist – and which is distinguished by a rigour and directness which Smither has described as aiming, above all, at truth. Recurring themes include the elusive and deceptive nature of language, and a pervasive interest in Catholicism – particularly in the sense of universal – which is all-embracing in its acceptance of the world in its contradictions.
Smither’s extensive body of poetry has often and, for me, regrettably, overshadowed her prose work. It is in her short stories and novels in which she most powerfully expresses a moving tenderness to the human condition, though the hand of a poet is certainly evident in prose which is characterised by such intensity of image, while paying close attention to the workings of language.
I read Elizabeth Smither because she writes about wonderfully smart and complex women, offering sensitive insight into their domestic lives and relationships.
I read Elizabeth Smither for the optimistic and freeing possibilities in her resistance to closure or conclusion, in character, narrative and, also, in life more broadly. Her stories acknowledge the uncontrollable messiness of life, the ragged edges of a self, the chaos of experience, the many aspects of an individual, and finds melody in the discord. Using multiple narrative perspectives and voices, moving between multiple places and times, her novels and stories accumulate the facets of a life and narrative without ever suggesting that these can be exhausted.
I read Elizabeth Smither because in her books no-one is ordinary; no matter how banal their daily routines, the people in her stories are endlessly complex and interesting in their emotional and intellectual lives. Indeed, it’s precisely in the mundane that there’s a glimpse of the transcendent, something larger that’s evident in the smallnesses of the everyday. These characters are written by an author who genuinely seems to like them, who observes with an irony both detached and empathetic, forgiving poor choices and personal inadequacies as necessary part of a glorious whole, while always refraining from judgement.
I read Elizabeth Smither for the powerful sense of movement and action in her work, for the athletic flexibility of her intellect.
I read Elizabeth Smither to be immersed in worlds which are themselves immersed in literature, celebrating the beauty of words, the power of a lyric, the transformative possibilities of just the right line of poetry. A literary motif might be a starting point for a story, and her characters and narrators are often readers themselves (or sometimes librarians, as was Smither herself), always framed by a rich literary context: they quote poetry and philosophy, compare themselves to literary figures, are changed by what they’ve read. Writers and their luminous words are alive in Smither’s writing and their effects ripple ever outwards: hers are worlds I feel at home in.
Accolades
Ockham New Zealand Book Award for Poetry (2018)
Sarah Broom Prize for Poetry (2016)
Prime Minister’s Award for Literary Achievement in poetry (2008)
Member of the New Zealand Order of Merit (2004)
Creative NZ Grant (2004)
Finalist for the Montana New Zealand Book Awards (2004)
Awarded an honorary DLitt from the University of Auckland for contributions to literature (2004)
Te Mata Poet Laureate (2002)
Montana New Zealand Book Award for Poetry (2000)
New Zealand Book Award for Poetry (1990)
Lilian Ida Smith Award (1989)
Literary Fund Travelling Bursary (1988)
Scholarship in Letters in (1987) & (1992)
Auckland University Literary Fellowship (1984)
Freda Buckland Award (1983)
Writing Bursary Award (1977)
Links
Read NZ Te Pou Muramura writer page
NZ Electronic Poetry Centre poet page
The Poetry Archive poet page
Penguin Books author page
Auckland University Press author page
Cape Catley author page
ANZRB review of Angel Train (Feb, 2026)
ANZL review of My American Chair (Dec, 2022)
RNZ interview discussing Night Horse (May, 2018)
Ockham NZ Book Award Announcement (May, 2018)
ANZL interview by David Hill (Sept, 2016)
Stuff.co.nz interview following 2016 Sarah Broome Prize (May, 2016)
Booksellers NZ article following 2016 Sarah Broom Prize (May, 2016)
Radio NZ interview (July, 2013)
.
'The thirty-five of us were in the country of dream-merchants, and strange things were bound to happen.' - Anne Kennedy
